Caleb Downs and Sonny Styles: Ohio State’s Dynamic Defensive Duo
In the world of college football, few programs boast a defensive lineage as storied as Ohio State’s. The Buckeyes have consistently produced elite defensive talent, and the 2025 season is no exception. Two players who have emerged as cornerstones of Ohio State’s defense are safety Caleb Downs and linebacker Sonny Styles. Both have been named to the prestigious Lott IMPACT Trophy Watch List, an honor bestowed upon the nation’s top defensive players. This recognition has sparked a debate among fans and analysts alike: Who is the true defensive alpha in Columbus?
Caleb Downs: The Versatile Safety
A Transfer That Paid Immediate Dividends
Caleb Downs made headlines when he transferred from Alabama to Ohio State, bringing with him a wealth of experience and accolades. In his freshman season with the Crimson Tide, Downs recorded 107 tackles and two interceptions, establishing himself as one of the premier defensive backs in the country. His decision to join the Buckeyes was seen as a game-changer for Ohio State’s defense.
Defensive Impact and Leadership
Upon his arrival, Downs immediately made his presence felt. In his debut game against Michigan State, he recorded six tackles, including a tackle for loss, showcasing his ability to disrupt plays and read offenses. His versatility allowed defensive coordinator Jim Knowles to employ various schemes, including three-safety looks, to keep opposing offenses guessing .
Beyond his physical skills, Downs quickly became a leader on the field. Teammate Jordan Hancock described him as “an on-field coach,” highlighting his ability to communicate and elevate the play of those around him .
Statistical Prowess
In the 2024 season, Downs led the Buckeyes with 34 solo tackles and ranked third with 62 total tackles. He also contributed 6.5 tackles for loss, an interception, and three pass breakups. His performance earned him first-team All-Big Ten honors and the Tatum-Woodson Defensive Back of the Year award .
Sonny Styles: The Emerging Linebacker
From Safety to Linebacker
Sonny Styles, a former five-star recruit, began his Ohio State career as a safety. However, with the addition of Downs, Styles was moved to linebacker, a position that better suits his physical attributes and playing style. Standing at 6’4″ and weighing 235 pounds, Styles possesses the size and athleticism to excel in the linebacker role .
Defensive Contributions
In the 2024 season, Styles led the Buckeyes with 76 total tackles and added 6.5 tackles for loss, three pass breakups, and a fumble recovery. His ability to cover ground quickly and make plays in both the run and pass game made him a valuable asset to Ohio State’s defense. His performance earned him second-team All-Big Ten honors .
Leadership and Potential
Styles’ transition to linebacker has allowed him to take on more leadership responsibilities. His experience in the secondary provides him with a unique perspective, enabling him to read offenses and make adjustments on the fly. As he continues to develop, Styles has the potential to become one of the top linebackers in the nation.
The Debate: Who Is the True Defensive Alpha?
The question of who is the true defensive leader in Columbus is a topic of much discussion. Both Downs and Styles bring unique skills and attributes to the table. Downs’ versatility and leadership in the secondary have been instrumental in Ohio State’s defensive schemes. Meanwhile, Styles’ physicality and playmaking ability at linebacker have made him a force in the middle of the defense.
Ultimately, the answer may not be as straightforward as choosing one over the other. Both players complement each other, forming a dynamic duo that enhances the overall strength of Ohio State’s defense. Their combined talents make the Buckeyes’ defense one of the most formidable in college football.
Caleb Downs and Sonny Styles represent the future of Ohio State’s defense. Their inclusion on the Lott IMPACT Trophy Watch List is a testament to their exceptional abilities and potential. As the 2025 season progresses, all eyes will be on these two players as they continue to lead the Buckeyes’ defensive charge. Whether it’s Downs’ versatility in the secondary or Styles’ dominance at linebacker, both players are poised to make significant impacts on the field and solidify their places among the elite defenders in college football.
