In a declaration that has sparked fervent debate among college football enthusiasts and historians, LSU Tigers quarterback Joe Burrow has officially been proclaimed the Greatest of All Time (GOAT) in NCAA men’s football. This monumental title was bestowed upon him after triumphing over three fiercely competitive rivals: Georgia Bulldogs’ legendary running back Herschel Walker, Texas Tech’s prolific wide receiver Michael Crabtree, and another unnamed icon whose shadow looms large in the annals of the sport.
The very notion of a “GOAT” in college football is inherently subjective, a battle waged with statistics, iconic moments, national championships, and the intangible aura surrounding truly transcendent players. However, Joe Burrow’s 2019 season with LSU stands as perhaps the most statistically dominant and culturally impactful single season in college football history, providing a formidable foundation for his claim.
Joe Burrow’s journey to GOAT status is unlike any other. After three seasons as a backup at Ohio State, he transferred to LSU, and after a solid but unspectacular 2018 season, he embarked on what many now consider the greatest individual season by a college quarterback. In 2019, Burrow shattered NCAA and SEC records, throwing for an astounding 5,671 yards and 60 touchdowns, with just 6 interceptions. He completed an astonishing 76.3% of his passes, a testament to his precision and command of LSU’s high-octane offense under then-offensive coordinator Joe Brady.
Beyond the raw numbers, Burrow’s leadership, poise, and ability to elevate the play of everyone around him were legendary. He led LSU to an undefeated 15-0 season, culminating in a College Football Playoff National Championship victory. His performances in the SEC Championship Game against Georgia and the Playoff semi-final and final were masterpieces, showcasing his ability to thrive under immense pressure. He won the Heisman Trophy by the largest margin in history, receiving 90.7% of the first-place votes. His transformation from a relatively unknown transfer to an undisputed national champion and top NFL draft pick captivated the nation. Burrow’s story is a compelling narrative of perseverance, unparalleled single-season dominance, and ultimate team success.
To be declared the GOAT, Burrow had to surpass some of the most revered names in college football history.
Herschel Walker (Georgia Bulldogs, Running Back):
Herschel Walker is, without question, one of the most physically dominant and consistently excellent players to ever grace a college football field. From 1980 to 1982, Walker was a force of nature for the Georgia Bulldogs. As a true freshman in 1980, he led Georgia to an undefeated national championship, rushing for 1,616 yards and 15 touchdowns. He was a consensus All-American in all three of his seasons and finished in the top three of the Heisman Trophy voting every year, finally winning the coveted award in 1982. By the end of his collegiate career, he held 11 NCAA records, 16 SEC records, and 41 Georgia records, including 5,259 rushing yards in just three seasons – an NCAA record for a three-year career. Walker’s combination of power, speed, and endurance was unmatched, and he carried his team to a remarkable 33-3 record during his tenure. His consistent individual brilliance and the national championship he delivered as a freshman make his case for GOAT status incredibly strong, particularly for those who value sustained multi-year dominance.
Michael Crabtree (Texas Tech Red Raiders, Wide Receiver):
Michael Crabtree’s collegiate career, though shorter than others, was nothing short of revolutionary for a wide receiver. Playing for Texas Tech from 2007 to 2008 in Mike Leach’s iconic “Air Raid” offense, Crabtree redefined what a college receiver could achieve. As a freshman in 2007, he exploded onto the scene, setting FBS single-season freshman records with 134 receptions, 1,962 receiving yards, and 22 touchdowns. He became the first freshman ever to win the Biletnikoff Award, given to the nation’s best wide receiver. He followed that up with another sensational season in 2008, recording 97 receptions for 1,165 yards and 19 touchdowns, winning his second Biletnikoff Award – the only player to ever do so. His legendary game-winning touchdown catch against No. 1 Texas in 2008 remains one of college football’s most iconic plays. Crabtree’s impact was undeniable, and his unprecedented individual statistics for a wide receiver challenged the traditional notion that a running back or quarterback had to be the best player in the sport. His case rests on pioneering individual statistical dominance at a position not typically associated with GOAT discussions, and the sheer spectacle he brought to every game.
The unstated fourth rival in this GOAT debate is a fascinating element, allowing for speculation and highlighting the breadth of college football’s greatest. Several individuals could fill this spot, each with a compelling argument:
- Tim Tebow (Florida Gators, Quarterback): Tebow’s unique blend of rushing power, passing ability, and unparalleled leadership led Florida to two national championships (2006, 2008) and a Heisman Trophy (2007). His “Tebow Time” phenomenon and iconic speeches captured the imagination of a generation, making him one of the most beloved and impactful college players ever. His dual-threat capabilities and championship pedigree are undeniable.
- Archie Griffin (Ohio State Buckeyes, Running Back): The only two-time Heisman Trophy winner (1974, 1975). This alone places him in an incredibly exclusive club. His sustained excellence over multiple seasons for a perennial power like Ohio State is a testament to his incredible skill and durability.
- Barry Sanders (Oklahoma State Cowboys, Running Back): While only one season, Sanders’ 1988 Heisman-winning campaign is arguably the most dominant single season by a running back in college football history: 2,628 rushing yards and 37 touchdowns. It was a statistical marvel that often comes up in debates about pure individual brilliance.
- Bo Jackson (Auburn Tigers, Running Back): A Heisman winner (1985) who transcended football with his multi-sport athleticism. Jackson was an electrifying runner with unmatched power and speed, capable of jaw-dropping plays that left opponents in awe. His legend extends beyond pure stats due to his incredible athletic gifts.
The selection of one of these, or another deserving figure like Charles Woodson, captures the diversity of positions and eras that contribute to the GOAT discussion.
The decision to declare Joe Burrow the GOAT, while sure to invite passionate disagreement, likely stems from a combination of factors that, when combined, create an almost unassailable case:
- Unprecedented Single-Season Dominance: Burrow’s 2019 season wasn’t just great; it was historically dominant in a way that surpassed statistical benchmarks thought unattainable. The combination of passing yards, touchdowns, completion percentage, and efficiency was simply mind-boggling.
- Quarterback Impact: In modern football, the quarterback is arguably the most impactful position. Burrow’s ability to elevate an entire offense and orchestrate a flawless championship run from that position is a powerful argument. While a running back or receiver can be phenomenal, the quarterback touches the ball every offensive snap and directs the entire operation.
- Championship Pedigree: He capped his historic season with a national championship, leaving no doubt about his ability to deliver under the brightest lights.
- Narrative Arc: His underdog story, from Ohio State backup to Heisman winner and national champion, adds a compelling human element to his statistical and competitive achievements. It makes his journey resonate deeply with fans.
- Modern Era Context: While comparing players across different eras is difficult, Burrow’s success came in the modern era of complex defenses and intense national scrutiny, making his accomplishments even more impressive.
Ultimately, while the debate will forever rage, the declaration of Joe Burrow as the NCAA men’s football GOAT highlights a player who, for one unforgettable season, achieved a level of individual and team success that set a new standard for excellence at the collegiate level. He stands as a testament to what happens when supreme talent meets perfect execution and unwavering leadership, leaving an indelible mark on the sport he so masterfully commanded.
