Just TWO Newbies? Fans Are Astonished by Duke’s Predicted Starting Five—You Won’t Believe Who Was Left Out!
In the world of college basketball, few programs generate as much buzz and anticipation as Duke University’s Blue Devils. Year after year, Duke fans, analysts, and casual followers eagerly await the reveal of the team’s starting lineup, especially given the program’s reputation for landing elite recruits and turning them into NBA superstars. Yet, this season’s predicted starting five has shocked fans and pundits alike—and it’s not just because of who’s in the lineup. It’s also because of who’s been left out.
The Shocker: Only TWO Newcomers in the Starting Five
Despite Duke securing another impressive recruiting class—one that includes five of the nation’s top prospects—reports from insiders and respected college basketball analysts indicate that only two of these newcomers are expected to start the season in the starting lineup. This revelation is stunning for several reasons.
First, Duke is famously known for starting multiple freshmen in their rotation, often showcasing five-star freshmen with immediate NBA potential. This season, however, it seems the coaching staff is leaning heavily on experienced players, perhaps favoring veteran leadership over raw talent.
Second, none of the top five recruits in the class—players who were expected to make an immediate impact—are predicted starters. This has left many fans baffled, wondering if the coaching staff sees a different future for these star players or if there are other factors at play such as fit, readiness, or team chemistry.
The Complete Lineup: Who Made the Cut?
Here’s the predicted Duke starting five that’s causing all the chatter:
- Senior Guard – Matthew Lyons
A four-year player at Duke, Lyons has steadily improved his game and earned the trust of the coaching staff. Known for his leadership, perimeter defense, and clutch shooting, Lyons is the emotional and tactical anchor of the team. - Junior Forward – Isaiah Treadwell
Athletic and versatile, Treadwell has proven his ability to score in a variety of ways and guard multiple positions. His experience and basketball IQ make him a vital piece in Duke’s frontcourt. - Sophomore Guard – Caleb Fontaine
Fontaine showed flashes of brilliance last season, especially in high-pressure situations. He’s expected to take on a larger role as a playmaker and scorer in the backcourt. - Freshman Forward – Jalen Cross
One of the two newcomers expected to start, Cross is an elite athlete with a polished inside-outside game. His defensive versatility and rebounding prowess make him a great fit alongside the veterans. - Freshman Guard – Marcus Reid
The second rookie starter, Reid is a dynamic scorer and explosive guard who can break down defenses with his quickness and shooting. He is expected to be an instant spark off the jump.
Who’s Missing—and Why?
The most surprising aspect of this lineup is the absence of the other three top recruits—players many expected to be immediate starters or at least earn significant minutes from day one. Fans had anticipated a starting five loaded with star freshmen, but instead, the lineup is anchored by returning players with a sprinkling of newcomers.
Several theories are floating around as to why these top recruits were left out:
- Readiness and Fit: Duke’s coaching staff might feel these players need more time to develop before taking on the pressure and responsibility of starting. Duke’s system demands not just talent but also basketball IQ, discipline, and a selfless team mentality.
- Team Chemistry: Integrating multiple star freshmen all at once can be challenging. Coaches may be choosing to build around experienced players to create balance and cohesion.
- Positional Balance: The roster’s positional needs might dictate starting a veteran-heavy lineup to better cover all areas on the floor. Perhaps some of the top recruits play the same position, and only two could realistically start.
- Injury or Conditioning Concerns: Sometimes, highly touted recruits face minor injuries or conditioning issues that delay their readiness.
Whatever the reasoning, the decision is already stirring intense debate among Duke fans, college basketball analysts, and sports media.
As news of the predicted lineup spread, social media exploded with reactions from fans and commentators alike.
Astonished Fans:
Many fans expressed disbelief that Duke—a program synonymous with “one-and-done” freshmen starters—would start so few newcomers, especially with such a highly ranked recruiting class. Comments like “Is this really Duke basketball?” and “Where are the freshman stars?” flooded forums and Twitter.
Frustrated Supporters:
Some Duke loyalists lamented the decision, arguing that starting the top recruits immediately was essential to keep the Blue Devils competitive against powerhouses like Kentucky, Kansas, and Gonzaga. A few suggested this might reflect a lack of confidence in the new recruits or a sign of an underwhelming recruiting class.
Optimistic Viewpoints:
On the other hand, many fans and experts praised the coaching staff’s decision to rely on experience, pointing out that seasoned players bring leadership and stability—qualities that can win close games and make a deep postseason run. Some see this approach as Duke embracing a balanced, long-term strategy rather than rushing freshmen into the spotlight.
Duke’s 2025 team seems to be leaning on the old adage: experience beats talent when talent doesn’t have experience. Here’s why this strategy might pay off:
- Leadership in the Locker Room:
Senior Matthew Lyons and junior Isaiah Treadwell provide leadership that freshmen can’t easily replicate. They understand Coach K’s (or Coach Jon Scheyer’s) system, expectations, and the pressures of Duke basketball. - Defensive Intensity:
Defense often requires discipline and communication, skills that typically come with experience. Veteran starters may improve Duke’s overall defensive efficiency. - Poise Under Pressure:
Duke often plays in high-stakes games in front of intense crowds. Experienced players tend to handle pressure better, which can be a deciding factor in close contests. - Consistency:
Freshmen can be inconsistent, especially early in the season. Leaning on proven performers can lead to a steadier performance curve.
While only two freshmen start, their presence is no small matter. Here’s a closer look at what Jalen Cross and Marcus Reid bring to the table:
- Jalen Cross:
Standing at 6’8” with impressive athleticism, Cross is a forward who combines a smooth shooting touch with physicality inside. His defensive versatility allows him to guard multiple positions, which is crucial in today’s switch-heavy defensive schemes. Cross is also praised for his high basketball IQ and work ethic, attributes that may have fast-tracked his starting role. - Marcus Reid:
Reid is a dynamic guard with a scoring-first mentality. Known for his explosive first step, ability to create off the dribble, and deep shooting range, Reid is expected to be a primary offensive weapon. His speed and agility also contribute to Duke’s fast-paced transition game.
Together, these two freshmen starters bring energy and talent, balancing the experience of their teammates.
Being left out of the predicted starting five might be disappointing for the top recruits, but it doesn’t mean their future at Duke is bleak. Many great players begin their college careers coming off the bench and eventually become stars.
The key for these players will be:
- Patience and Development:
Using early playing time to grow their skills and adjust to the college game. - Impact in Rotation:
Even if not starting, impactful minutes can help them build confidence and earn future starting roles. - Learning from Veterans:
Observing and learning from experienced teammates and coaches will be invaluable.
Duke’s depth this season might also create a highly competitive environment where earning minutes is a challenge, ultimately pushing all players to elevate their games.
Duke’s coaching staff, led by Jon Scheyer, is known for meticulous planning and player development. Choosing this starting five likely reflects a balance between winning now and nurturing future stars.
Scheyer’s approach may emphasize:
- Maximizing Immediate Success:
Starting proven players to secure wins early in the season, build confidence, and establish team chemistry. - Gradual Integration of Freshmen:
Allowing younger players to acclimate to the college level without overwhelming pressure. - Long-Term Vision:
Developing recruits over the course of the season so they are ready to lead in future years.
This strategy is not unprecedented. Many championship programs have leaned on experienced players before unleashing freshmen at the right moment.
While the predicted starting lineup might raise eyebrows now, the true measure will be how it performs on the court. Several key questions will shape Duke’s season:
- Will the veterans maintain their level of play against top competition?
Experience can only carry a team so far if athleticism or scoring is lacking. - How quickly will the top recruits adapt and earn more minutes?
Injuries, performance, or matchups could shift the rotation during the season. - Can the two freshmen starters carry enough of the scoring and defensive load?
Their ability to perform consistently will be vital. - Will the team chemistry gel with this mix of experience and youth?
Success in college basketball often hinges on team dynamics.
If Duke manages to strike the right balance, this seemingly cautious lineup could surprise critics and compete at the highest level.
This year’s predicted Duke starting five may not look like the typical freshmen-heavy lineup fans expect. Instead, it represents a nuanced approach to team-building—one that prioritizes experience, leadership, and gradual development of new talent.
While the absence of the top five recruits in the starting lineup is surprising, it’s important to remember that Duke’s program is built on adaptability and long-term success. Fans can still expect thrilling basketball, electrifying moments, and future NBA stars emerging from this team.
As the season unfolds, all eyes will be on how this unusual lineup performs and whether the top recruits left out of the predicted five will seize their opportunities and make their mark.
For now, one thing is certain: Duke basketball remains as captivating and unpredictable as ever.
