Notre Dame head coach Marcus Freeman shares the key qualities he expects from quarterbacks CJ Carr and Kenny Minchey as they compete for the starting role.
The quarterback competition at Notre Dame is shaping up to be one of the most intriguing storylines heading into the upcoming season, and head coach Marcus Freeman has been clear about what he wants to see from his two primary contenders, CJ Carr and Kenny Minchey. Both young men bring different strengths and styles to the table, but the common thread is Freeman’s emphasis on leadership, consistency, and the ability to execute under pressure.
Marcus Freeman understands that the quarterback position is the most critical spot on the field, especially for a program like Notre Dame, which prides itself on a balanced attack and disciplined play. This season, the Irish are looking for a signal-caller who not only can make big plays but who can also be a steadying presence in the locker room and on the practice field. In his remarks, Freeman has emphasized that the competition between Carr and Minchey is about more than just arm strength or physical ability; it’s about mental toughness, preparation, and how each player embodies the values Notre Dame football stands for.
CJ Carr, who has shown flashes of brilliance during his time with the Irish, comes into the competition with a solid grasp of the offense and a competitive fire that Freeman finds encouraging. He has the ability to make plays both through the air and with his legs, which adds an extra dimension to the offense. However, Freeman notes that Carr needs to demonstrate improved decision-making, particularly in high-pressure situations where split-second choices can dictate the outcome of a game. The coach wants to see Carr take command of the huddle with confidence, make accurate throws consistently, and show that he can handle the physical and mental grind of a full season as the starter.
On the other hand, Kenny Minchey offers a slightly different skill set. He is known for his poise in the pocket and his ability to read defenses quickly, qualities that are invaluable in Notre Dame’s complex offensive schemes. Freeman has praised Minchey’s work ethic and football IQ, highlighting that he’s a student of the game who puts in the extra hours studying film and perfecting his footwork. While Minchey might not possess the same level of mobility as Carr, his accuracy and calm under pressure make him a formidable candidate. Freeman is looking for Minchey to translate that preparation into on-field performance, showing that he can lead the offense effectively and minimize mistakes.
The competition is far from just physical or technical; it’s deeply rooted in character. Marcus Freeman has reiterated that the quarterback must be a leader who sets the tone for the entire team. He wants to see who can rally their teammates, maintain composure during adversity, and consistently push themselves and those around them to improve. This leadership aspect is crucial because the quarterback is often the face of the program and the bridge between the coaching staff and players. In practice sessions, Freeman watches how Carr and Minchey communicate with their receivers, offensive linemen, and coaches, assessing who naturally steps into that leadership role.
Freeman has also stressed the importance of resilience in this competition. Football is a game of highs and lows, and the ability to bounce back from mistakes or setbacks is essential. He wants both quarterbacks to embrace the grind and show mental toughness when things don’t go their way. Whether it’s a bad throw, a misread, or a tough loss, the quarterback who can keep his head up and lead by example will earn the trust of the coaching staff and teammates alike.
The coach’s approach to this competition is methodical. He is not rushing the decision but allowing both Carr and Minchey ample reps in practice and scrimmages to demonstrate their growth. Freeman emphasizes daily improvement and attention to detail, looking for the player who not only performs well but who also learns from coaching points and shows adaptability. This developmental focus aligns with Notre Dame’s tradition of cultivating not just athletes but mature, well-rounded individuals prepared for the challenges of collegiate football and beyond.
Another key element Freeman looks for is how each quarterback manages the offense in terms of tempo and game management. Notre Dame’s offensive philosophy often involves a mix of aggressive passing and disciplined running, requiring the quarterback to have a good feel for when to push the pace and when to slow things down. Freeman wants to see which player can best control the flow of the game, keep defenses off balance, and minimize turnovers. Ball security is paramount in this regard, and he expects both Carr and Minchey to demonstrate precision and smart decision-making in every drill and live situation.
Freeman has noted that special teams and situational football are also part of what he evaluates in the quarterbacks. How they handle two-minute drills, red-zone opportunities, and pressure-packed moments reveals a lot about their readiness to lead. This is where experience can be a differentiator, and both players are being tested on their ability to perform when the stakes are highest. Freeman values the player who can elevate his performance during these critical junctures, showing poise and accuracy when it matters most.
In addition to on-field performance, the coach places significant weight on preparation off the field. He praises both Carr and Minchey for their commitment to film study, understanding the nuances of the playbook, and working closely with the offensive staff. Freeman believes that the quarterback who invests the most in preparation will be the one who executes best under pressure. This work ethic is a major factor in the competition because it reflects a player’s dedication to the craft and readiness to lead a prestigious program like Notre Dame.
Freeman’s vision for the quarterback position is not just about athletic prowess but about setting a cultural tone for the team. He expects his quarterback to be a role model in the community and within the locker room, embodying the values of discipline, respect, and accountability. This holistic approach to leadership aligns with Notre Dame’s identity and the expectations placed on its student-athletes. The coach has made it clear that the player who earns the starting job will be someone who can carry these responsibilities with pride and maturity.
The battle between CJ Carr and Kenny Minchey is also reflective of the broader strategy that Marcus Freeman is implementing as head coach. He values competition as a tool for growth, pushing players to raise their standards and never settle for mediocrity. This quarterback competition is not just about picking a starter; it’s about fostering a culture of excellence and resilience that will benefit the entire team. Freeman’s message to both players has been consistent: embrace the challenge, work hard every day, and let your performance speak for itself.
As the competition unfolds in practices and scrimmages, Freeman continues to provide feedback and guidance, encouraging both quarterbacks to focus on incremental improvements. He wants to see who can sustain their performance over time, adapt to different defensive looks, and show leadership through action. This patience in the evaluation process shows the coach’s confidence in his players and his commitment to making the best decision for the team’s success.
The stakes are high, as the starting quarterback will not only lead the Irish offense but also carry the hopes of a passionate fan base eager to see Notre Dame return to national prominence. Freeman understands this pressure and has prepared both Carr and Minchey to handle it with professionalism and grit. The competition has already generated excitement among fans and analysts alike, who appreciate the talent and potential both quarterbacks bring to the table.
Ultimately, Marcus Freeman’s criteria for choosing between CJ Carr and Kenny Minchey go beyond statistics and highlight reels. It’s about finding the player who can consistently execute the game plan, inspire teammates, and handle the pressures that come with leading one of college football’s most storied programs. The competition is a testament to the depth and quality of Notre Dame’s roster and Freeman’s vision for building a team that competes at the highest level.
As the Irish gear up for the season, the quarterback competition will remain a focal point in training camps and preseason games. Fans will watch closely as both CJ Carr and Kenny Minchey strive to prove they have what it takes to wear the Notre Dame jersey as the starting quarterback. Under Marcus Freeman’s watchful eye, this battle promises to push both players to new heights and ultimately position Notre Dame for success on the field.
In the end, the quarterback who emerges victorious will be the one who embodies everything Freeman expects: leadership, preparation, resilience, and the ability to perform when it counts. This competition is more than just a contest; it’s a crucible that will shape the future of Notre Dame football and set the tone for the team’s journey ahead. For Marcus Freeman, it’s about selecting not just a player, but a leader who can carry the program’s legacy forward with pride and determination.
