Why Ty Simpson Could Be Alabama’s Secret Weapon in 2025: The Most Underrated QB in College Football?
When discussing the most underrated quarterback in college football today, Ty Simpson of the Alabama Crimson Tide deserves serious recognition. Despite media buzz around high-profile signal-callers nationwide, Simpson quietly leads a talented roster. In a crowded field of prospects and headline grabbers, he stands out as a top‑tier performer whose consistency, leadership, and potential remain significantly underappreciated. This deep dive into Alabama roster rankings reveals why Ty Simpson should no longer be overlooked. By exploring his statistical growth, game‑winning poise, NFL potential, and its implications for Crimson Tide fans and scouts, this article answers the question: how did Alabama’s backup‑turned‑leader become the most underrated quarterback in college football?
Ty Simpson’s journey began at James Clemens High School in Madison, Alabama, where he earned five‑star status as a top recruit in the 2023 class. National analysts praised his arm talent, accuracy, and football intelligence. Upon joining the Crimson Tide, he redshirted his freshman season, spending time learning the playbook and developing under veteran coaches. That draft year allowed him to build confidence and grasp Alabama’s pro‑style system, which often evaluates quarterbacks on preparation as much as physical ability. Rarely do backups receive such seamless transitions to leadership roles—Ty’s rapid growth speaks to both his talent and Alabama’s quarterback development system.
Emerging as the starter in Year Two, Simpson demonstrated steady progression. In key mid‑season matchups against ranked opponents, he delivered under pressure, orchestrating drives with poise, making smart reads, and minimizing turnovers. Though his numbers may not yet rival those of national Heisman contenders, his touchdown‑to‑interception ratio, completion percentage, and fourth‑quarter composure built consistent trust among teammates and coaches. Critics pointed to modest passing yardage compared to flashier peers, but they didn’t account for Alabama’s run‑heavy offensive philosophy and balanced playcalling. In a system that cherishes ball security and situational execution, Simpson’s efficiency overshadowed raw volume. While other quarterbacks traded interceptions or erratic performances for gaudier stat lines, Ty Simpson quietly won games.
Search engine queries like “Alabama quarterback underrated”, “Ty Simpson stats 2024”, “Crimson Tide roster rankings quarterback”, and “college football sleeper QB to watch” increasingly return content spotlighting his rise. Growing online interest reflects coaches and fans recognizing his consistency: game‑winning drives, perfect pocket presence, and daring downfield strikes. Analysts now cite him as a draft sleeper and a possible first‑round pick if he continues refining mechanics and decision‑making. Despite this, many publications still understate his impact, often overshadowed by bigger names from Michigan, Ohio State, Texas, or USC. That shadow only deepens Simpson’s credentials as the most underrated quarterback in the college game.
Looking at roster rankings, Alabama’s depth chart now clearly shows Simpson at the top. Behind him, several talented quarterbacks vie for reps. But no understudy matches Ty’s live‑game experience or leadership presence in the locker room. His command of the offense, trust from offensive line and receivers, and natural chemistry during practice and games make him the default anchor. When seasoned backups or transfers falter, Simpson remains the consistent constant. His ability to absorb pressure, evade sacks, stay poised, and extend plays sets him apart from other prospects who rely heavily on athleticism rather than decision‑making.
The national narrative often emphasizes dual‑threat QBs and highlight reels, but Simpson’s style harks back to traditional pocket command. He reads defenses pre‑snap, scans the field post‑snap, and delivers precise throws with anticipation. Few quarterbacks at the college level demonstrate such maturity and control, treating each game like a professional audition. His arm strength complements his accuracy, especially on intermediate and deep routes that stretch defenses. As defenders close in, Simpson escapes pressure intelligently, sets his feet, and delivers strikes on the run. That level of composure under duress remains rare among peers—even among Power Five starters.
Yet despite all this, mainstream ranking lists and sports talk rarely rank him among the very top QBs. On ESPN polls, Sports Illustrated prospects lists, and CBS Sports quarterback rankings, Simpson either misses the cut or lands barely inside the top 10. That discrepancy between his intangible strengths and his public perception marks the core of his underrated status. When he posts high completion percentages, efficient touchdown drives, and game‑saving moments, analysts still focus on his overall passing yards or highlight economy-style fellow QBs posting bigger box scores. In reality, efficiency is elite—not volume—and Ty Simpson embodies that.
For Crimson Tide fans and recruiting watchers, Simpson’s rise reinforces what Alabama has long done best: develop elite talents behind experienced quarterbacks, then seamlessly hand over the reins when the time is right. His presence ensures the Tide’s offense stays disciplined, efficient, and tough to beat. Meanwhile, scouts now highlight his NFL projection: a quarterback who can adjust quickly to pro defenses, make NFL‑level reads, and deliver accurate throws in tight windows. With each game, he closes the gap between the college and NFL evaluation metrics, winning over skeptics as a high‑floor, potentially high‑upside pro prospect.
Optimizing this kind of article for SEO, relevant long‑tail keywords might include: “Ty Simpson Crimson Tide quarterback underrated”, “Alabama roster quarterback rankings Ty Simpson”, “college football underrated quarterbacks 2025”, “Ty Simpson stats efficiency rating”, and “NFL draft sleeper quarterback Alabama”. Incorporating these terms naturally helps search engines identify the article’s relevance to audiences searching for hidden gems, Crimson Tide roster updates, and sleeper prospects. By interweaving such phrases with narrative flow, the article both reads engagingly for fans and ranks strongly in SEO results.
In summary, Ty Simpson’s performance and development trajectory put him at the top of Alabama’s quarterback depth chart, while public perception still underestimates him. Game after game, his consistent execution, smart decision‑making, and growing leadership offset the flashier competitors. He thrives in a system that values ball security and situational mastery—qualities that don’t always make highlight reels, but win games. He writes a new chapter in Crimson Tide quarterback tradition: a polished pocket passer who peaks under pressure and delivers results when it matters most.
As long as he continues on this path, the narrative must shift. With NCAA attention gravitating toward efficiency‑oriented QBs, NFL evaluators tracking his every move, and fans tuning into Alabama’s roster rankings, Ty Simpson is poised to shake off the label “underrated” and step into the daylight as one of college football’s elite signal‑callers.
