In the history of the Indiana Fever, only two players have accomplished this: After Caitlin Clark, Kelsey Mitchell

Caitlin Clark was the first. During her sensational rookie year in 2024, she exploded for 35 points, eight assists, and six made threes in a thrilling 110–109 win over the Dallas Wings. That performance stood alone until Kelsey Mitchell matched it later . The WNBA even noted on X (now X) that “Kelsey Mitchell joins Caitlin Clark as the only players in @IndianaFever franchise history to record 35 + PTS, 5 + AST, and 5 + 3PM in a game!” . That statement clearly underscores that only those two players have hit all three thresholds in a single game.

Caitlin Clark achieved the feat first in September 2024, finishing with 35 points, eight assists, and six threes. In that same game, Kelsey Mitchell added 30 points, helping Indiana set a franchise record for points and matching a season‑high for made threes

Kelsey Mitchell then replicated the full combination herself later—without Clark—scoring 35 points, dishing out at least five assists, and knocking down at least five threes in another game (the particular opponent or date isn’t known in the summary, but it’s noted that she joined Clark in that elite franchise bucket)

To put it into broader context: Mitchell entered the league in 2018 as the No. 2 overall pick out of Ohio State. She steadily developed into Indiana’s go‑to scorer, leading the Fever in scoring from 2019 through 2022. By early 2025 she had accumulated 3,923 points, making her second all‑time in Fever scoring, with 558 three‑pointers, and ranked fourth in franchise assists (649)

When Clarke arrived as the first overall pick in the 2024 draft, everything accelerated. In her first season she shattered multiple records: rookie scoring (769 points), rookie 3‑pointers (122), WNBA single‑season assist total (337), and recorded the first triple‑double by a Fever rookie and the first triple‑double in Fever history. She was named Rookie of the Year and an All‑Star starter—and performances like her 35‑point, eight‑assist, six‑3PM outburst made her the first Fever player to record those numbers in one game

So Mitchell’s matching of that performance is especially noteworthy. Clark achieved it in a game where Mitchell also had 30 points (but fewer assists and 3PM than Clark). Later, Mitchell turned the tables in a separate game, delivering her own 35-point / 5-assist / 5‑3PM line—making her the only other player in franchise history to reach that stat trifecta

This accomplishment is significant not just for its statistical rarity but also in the context of the Fever’s franchise trajectory. Indiana had endured prolonged struggles and a playoff drought from 2016 to their 2024 return. During that stretch, Mitchell was the scoring anchor—even during seasons with single-digit wins. Then Clark joined in 2024, instantly revitalizing the team’s fortunes. With Mitchell and Clark forming one of the most explosive backcourts in WNBA history, Indiana returned to the playoffs for the first time since 2016 and finally broke through to a winning record mid‑season for the first time since 2019

Specifically, after the Olympic break in 2024, the Fever won six of seven games behind back‑to‑back monster performances from Clark and Mitchell. Mitchell averaged over 28 points per game in that stretch, with Clark supplying elite playmaking. Indiana officially clinched its playoff spot as the No. 6 seed, with that tandem central to the turnaround

Mitchell’s role grew even more in Clark’s absence in 2025. When Clark sat out with a groin injury early in the 2025 season, Kelsey stepped up. In one win over the Washington Mystics she dropped 24 points, tied her season-high, and helped carry the Fever when Clark was out. She was honored by the team as the “Stat Leader of the Game” in that context Later, she scored 35 points in another big win against the Chicago Sky—even without Clark in the lineup

So in summary: those two Fever players who share the franchise‑exclusive stat of at least 35 points, 5 assists, and 5 three‑pointers in a game are Caitlin Clark (first to do it, in September 2024) and Kelsey Mitchell (later achieved same line on her own). Only those two have reached all three thresholds in a single game in Indiana Fever history.