Marcus Freeman Continues to Outperform James Franklin in Recruiting, Showcasing His Formidable Ability to Build a Strong Football Program

In the highly competitive landscape of college football, recruiting is often the linchpin of sustained success. Coaches who can consistently attract top-tier talent set their programs on a trajectory that leads to winning seasons, bowl game appearances, and conference championships. Marcus Freeman, the current head coach of the Notre Dame Fighting Irish football team, has rapidly established himself as one of the most effective recruiters in the sport, even outpacing his predecessor James Franklin, who was known for his recruiting acumen during his tenure at Penn State. Freeman’s ability to attract and secure elite prospects underscores not only his compelling vision for Notre Dame football but also his skillful relationship-building, strategic insight, and deep understanding of the modern college football recruiting ecosystem.

The Importance of Recruiting in College Football

Recruiting is the lifeblood of any successful college football program. Unlike professional sports, where teams can acquire players through drafts and trades, college coaches must evaluate and convince young athletes — many still in high school — to commit to their program, often competing against dozens of other universities. The ability to secure commitments from high-ranking prospects can transform a team’s fortunes, enhancing on-field performance and elevating the program’s national profile.

James Franklin, during his years at Penn State (2014–2021), was widely recognized for revitalizing a program reeling from NCAA sanctions. Franklin’s recruiting efforts helped restore Penn State to national relevance, securing multiple top-25 recruiting classes. He built relationships with prospects, coaches, and high school programs, creating pipelines that brought in dynamic athletes. However, the recruiting landscape has evolved, and Marcus Freeman’s emerging success suggests he has adapted to and even advanced the art of recruiting in ways Franklin did not.

Marcus Freeman’s Recruiting Philosophy

Freeman’s recruiting success is rooted in his ability to connect with players on a personal level. Unlike some coaches who rely solely on traditional methods of recruiting, Freeman’s approach blends authenticity, cultural fit, and a forward-thinking strategy. As a relatively young head coach with a recent history as a defensive coordinator and linebacker coach, Freeman speaks the language of today’s recruits — understanding their priorities, concerns, and aspirations.

Freeman is not just selling Notre Dame’s rich football tradition; he’s selling a vision of development and opportunity. He emphasizes the holistic growth of his players — athletically, academically, and personally. This approach resonates deeply with recruits and their families, who often look beyond just the football program when choosing a college. His reputation as a strong defensive mind and former NFL assistant also assures recruits that they will receive top-tier coaching that prepares them for professional careers.

Outperforming James Franklin: Statistical Evidence and Recruiting Rankings

To measure Freeman’s impact compared to Franklin’s, one can look at recruiting rankings and commitments since Freeman took over Notre Dame’s program. Recruiting services like 247Sports, Rivals, and ESPN rank players and classes based on perceived talent and potential impact.

Since Freeman’s arrival, Notre Dame’s recruiting classes have consistently ranked in the top 15 nationally, often in the top 10. These rankings surpass the average recruiting rankings Penn State achieved under Franklin, particularly in the critical 2023 and 2024 recruiting cycles. Freeman’s ability to attract four- and five-star recruits in positions of need — quarterback, offensive line, wide receiver, and defensive back — has strengthened Notre Dame’s roster depth and future outlook.

Moreover, Freeman’s recruits have a higher retention rate, with fewer early transfers or decommitments, signaling strong satisfaction with the program’s culture and leadership. This contrasts with some of Franklin’s later classes at Penn State, where transfers and player dissatisfaction began to increase.

Building Strong Relationships: The Human Element in Recruiting

Recruiting is not just about talent evaluation but about building trust and relationships. Freeman’s background as a linebacker and coach gives him a unique perspective on what players need to succeed. His approachable demeanor and ability to relate to players on a personal level differentiate him from many coaches.

Freeman spends time visiting players in their communities, communicating regularly, and engaging with their families and coaches. This personalized attention makes players feel valued and understood, increasing their commitment to the program. Additionally, Freeman’s staff reflects diversity and experience, allowing Notre Dame to build connections with a wide range of high school programs across the country.

Strategic Vision and Adaptability

Marcus Freeman’s recruiting success also comes from his strategic vision. He understands the shifting dynamics of college football recruiting, including the impact of the NCAA transfer portal, Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals, and social media. Freeman’s staff leverages technology and analytics to identify prospects who fit their system and culture, rather than just chasing high-ranked names.

Freeman embraces the transfer portal as an extension of recruiting. His ability to add experienced college players fills immediate needs while developing younger recruits for the future. This dual approach balances short-term competitiveness with long-term program sustainability.

The evolving NIL landscape means recruits consider opportunities beyond the gridiron. Freeman and his staff work closely with Notre Dame’s compliance and marketing teams to assure recruits and their families that the university provides competitive NIL opportunities while maintaining integrity.

Developing Talent and Coaching Impact

Recruiting is only the first step; developing recruited talent into productive collegiate athletes is equally crucial. Freeman’s background as a defensive coordinator who developed NFL-caliber linebackers demonstrates his capability to nurture and maximize player potential.

This track record reassures recruits that they will receive expert coaching tailored to their strengths and areas for growth. Player development under Freeman translates to on-field success, further reinforcing Notre Dame’s attractiveness to future recruits.

Cultural Fit and Identity

Freeman has also excelled at communicating and reinforcing Notre Dame’s unique cultural identity — one that combines academic excellence, athletic competitiveness, and a strong community ethos. His recruits buy into the tradition of Notre Dame football, but more importantly, they embrace the opportunity to be part of something larger than themselves.

This cultural fit has reduced attrition rates and created a tight-knit team environment. Players and coaches speak openly about a shared mission, which Freeman fosters through transparency and inclusivity. This atmosphere contrasts with some of the challenges Franklin faced at Penn State as the program adjusted post-sanctions.

Challenges and Opportunities Ahead

While Freeman’s recruiting success is impressive, the challenge remains to translate this talent into consistent on-field success. College football is unforgiving, and even the best recruiting classes do not guarantee championships.

Moreover, Notre Dame competes in a uniquely competitive environment — as an independent program without conference affiliation, the Fighting Irish must convince recruits they can achieve national prominence and compete for titles without a traditional conference championship pathway.

Freeman’s challenge is to leverage recruiting momentum into sustained winning records, deep playoff runs, and bowl victories. If he continues to outperform Franklin’s recruiting achievements, he can firmly establish Notre Dame as a national powerhouse once again.

Marcus Freeman’s recruiting success relative to James Franklin showcases his formidable ability to build and sustain a top-tier football program. By blending personal connection, strategic vision, cultural alignment, and expert coaching, Freeman has positioned Notre Dame to compete at the highest levels for years to come. His continued excellence in recruiting is a testament to his leadership and understanding of the evolving college football landscape.

If Freeman maintains this trajectory, Notre Dame fans can look forward to a renaissance in Fighting Irish football — one built on talent, trust, and a commitment to excellence that echoes far beyond the recruiting trail.

Would you like me to expand on any particular section or add specific examples or player profiles?