The Bold Claim: “Super Bowl‑Caliber” from a Former Teammate
In late June 2025, Robbie Chosen—also known as former NFL wide receiver Robbie Anderson—made headlines by calling Baker Mayfield a “Super Bowl‑caliber QB.” Chosen, who briefly played with Mayfield in Carolina in 2022, highlighted his leadership, arm talent, and ability to galvanize teammates. During an appearance on Good Morning Football, Chosen said:
This wasn’t just off‑hand praise. Chosen noted that Mayfield, after being signed by the Panthers, immediately learned the offense and impacted the team’s dynamic from Day 1 of training camp . It was high praise from someone who shared a locker room with him, and it spoke volumes about Mayfield’s qualities.II. What Does “Super Bowl‑Caliber” Actually Mean?
Labeling a quarterback “Super Bowl‑caliber” suggests more than flashes of skill—it implies someone capable of carrying a team deep into the playoffs, who elevates teammates, executes under pressure, and consistently wins big games.
A. Leadership & Locker Room Impact
Beyond Xs and Os, a Super Bowl‑caliber QB must uplift those around him. Mayfield’s reputation in Tampa Bay underscores that:
- Authenticity & team chemistry: ESPN reported he “won over” the Buccaneers’ locker room with his genuine, down‑to‑earth demeanor. Teammates such as Mike Evans, John Wolford, and Luke Goedeke attested to his authentic leadership, noting his resilience and team‑first mentality (africa.espn.com).
- Peer respect: Travis Canales, their offensive coordinator, described how Mayfield “talks to” teammates struggling during games—providing emotional support and prompting better performance (africa.espn.com).
- Intangibles: Reddit observations reinforce his ethos: “He’s a guy that wants to see you be an absolute dawg, cheering you on,” and that he’ll “get in the trenches with you” (reddit.com). Another fan called it “the ultimate teammate” vibe.
These examples emphasize Mayfield’s capacity to unite and energize his team—an essential trait of championship QBs.
III. Playoff Performance & High‑Pressure Execution
To be Super Bowl worth, performance in big games matters. Mayfield has consistently delivered strong postseason performances.
A. Completion and Efficiency When It Counts
Data through 2025 highlights his playoff effectiveness:
- As of the end of the 2024 postseason, Mayfield owns the highest career playoff passer rating (minimum 150 attempts) in NFL history—105.9 (reddit.com, en.wikipedia.org).
- His playoff stats with Tampa Bay show a 66.3% completion rate across three games (bvmsports.com).
That’s not just solid—it’s elite production under pressure from the postseason’s most critical moments.
B. Signature Moments
One highlight that stands out: Mayfield orchestrated a late-game, game‑winning drive versus the 49ers, scrambling to avoid Nick Bosa and finding Rachaad White for a clutch 1st down. Tom Brady, calling the game for Fox, called it “one of the best plays I’ve ever seen a quarterback make” (tampabay.com).
IV. Statistical Growth & Season‑Over‑Season Improvement
While playoff brilliance matters, so does steady regular‑season performance. Mayfield’s ascent in Tampa Bay offers proof:
- 2023 with Bucs: Posted 4,044 yards, 28 TDs, 10 INTs, and a 64.3% completion rate (heavy.com).
- 2024 with Bucs: Reached career highs—4,500 yards, 41 TDs, 16 INTs, and an impressive 71.4% completion rate (tampabay.com).
Rick Stroud of the Tampa Bay Times noted that Mayfield led the league in yards and touchdowns, but also tied for most interceptions—highlighting a high-risk, high-reward approach inherent to fiery competitors .
In short, he improved year over year, refined his accuracy, stretched his capabilities—and underlined his ability to evolve, not plateau.
V. Resilience, Experience & Battle‑Hardened Toughness
Every Super Bowl champion QB has overcome adversity. Mayfield’s journey furnishes prime examples:
A. A Rocky Start, Yet Rising
- Despite being a Heisman‑winner and Browns’ No. 1 pick, his earlier years were tumultuous—labrum injuries, inconsistent offensive lines, and coaching instability.
- His 2021 season ended via season‑ending surgery
- The disastrous 2022 year with the Panthers saw his release—but even then, he adapted quickly and earned praise from teammates like Chosen and Rams’ staff
B. Finding His Home in Tampa Bay
After bouncing from Cleveland → Carolina → LA, the stability of Tampa Bay since 2023 seems ideal. Brad Johnson—Bucs’ former Super Bowl‑winning QB—observed that Mayfield “has got all the skill set… bounced from a couple of different teams and now he’s found his home. … He produces and he gets the most out of the players around him”
This maturation illustrates the classic narrative of an elite QB: early turmoil, learning, and then championship‑drive emergence.
VI. Community & Fan Perception: Love From the Locker Room to Reddit
A. Fans Notice the Difference
On Reddit, Bucs fans speak volumes:
These reactions reflect a broader sentiment: fans sense his shift from scrappy journeyman to dependable, inspiring leader.
B. Rookie to Comeback King
One fan wrote:
Savings aside from the award specifics, the mainstream perception is clear: Mayfield didn’t just return—he surpassed expectations.
A balanced view wouldn’t be complete without addressing criticisms.
A. Turnover Risk
Mayfield’s aggressive style brings turnovers. His 16 interceptions in 2024 led the league (tampabay.com). Strong QBs—especially critics—will demand fewer mistakes.
B. Consistency vs Flash
Commentary from The Athletic-quoting Reddit points out: “He’s exactly the kind of QB that can randomly look great to elite for like a month… but he will still have his games where he kinda looks like a bum” (reddit.com). That touches on his occasional volatility—a weakness of high-ceiling players.
C. Not Yet a Super Bowl Champion
Champion status requires a win. Until Mayfield raises the Lombardi, “Super Bowl‑caliber” remains aspirational. But most all-time greats were once called that before their breakthrough.
Evidence For:
- Peer praise: High-level endorsements from teammates like Chosen and Johnson.
- Elite playoff performance: Top-tier career playoff rating (105.9) (en.wikipedia.org).
- Leadership & intangibles: Strong locker-room unity and resilience under fire .
- Statistical growth: Increase in yardage, touchdowns, and completion rate from 2023 to 2024 .
- Redemption arc: From Heisman walk‑on, to NFL promise, to adversity, to resurgence.
- Turnover issues: High interception rates signal risk.
- Questionable consistency: Mayfield can oscillate between brilliance and mediocrity.
- Lack of ultimate accolade: No Super Bowl win yet.
Baker Mayfield ticks all the boxes of a QB on Super Bowl trajectory:
- He’s battle-tested and proven in playoff environments.
- His leadership style has revitalized Tampa’s locker room.
- His 2023–24 performance shows linear progression.
- Most importantly, trusted voices like Chosen emphatically believe in his championship potential.
Yes, he still has kinks to work out—primarily ball security and consistency—but all elite QBs have these issues at times.
All signs are pointing upward—with playoff record, endorsement, fan faith, and statistical improvement, he’s already earned his stripes as a Super Bowl‑caliber quarterback.
But the final verdict lies on Sunday, February 9, 2026 (Super Bowl LX in Las Vegas?). If Tampa Bay reaches “the Big Game,” and Mayfield executes with poise, leadership, and wins it—the acclaim transforms from adjectival praise to historical record. He’ll be rightfully recognized not just as capable, but as a champion.
- 🎯 Former teammate Robbie Chosen labeled him Super Bowl‑caliber, citing his leadership, arm talent, and overnight impact
- Elite playoff numbers (105.9 rating, 66% comp) show clutch performance .
- Locker-room chemistry and motivational intangibles rank him high among leaders
- Statistical breakout in 2024: 4,500 yards and 41 TDs with 71% completion Redemption story: from instability to steady anchor in Tampa
- Concerns remain: turnovers and occasional inconsistency, plus he still needs that ring.
Yes, Baker Mayfield, by every tangible and intangible measure—peer acclaim, playoff performance, leadership, and upward trajectory—is Super Bowl‑caliber. But only by winning one will that label transition from deserved aspiration to lasting legacy.
He stands at the brink: a QB with all the tools, the heart, and the momentum. The Lombardi Trophy awaits. Let’s see if he can bring it home.
Let me know if you’d like me to tighten certain sections, focus more heavily on stats, or explore deeper playoff game analyses!
